Moderna has dosed its first group of patients in the second phase of the clinical trial for its coronavirus vaccine. The company has led the pack of companies racing to come up with a viable vaccine to combat the pandemic so that people can return to work and a more normal life. As a result, share prices for Moderna surged last month after the company announced promising early results from the first stage of human trials. However, it now appears that Moderna may have over-hyped the results of the trial to benefit the company's bottom line.
In the days following the announcement of the first round trials, the company made $1.3 billion in a mass sale of shares to the public. At the same time, two Moderna executives—Chief Medical Officer Tal Zaks and Chief Technical Officer Lawrence Kim – sold off nearly $30 million of their combined shares. Those two sales were executed through automated trading programs for people and firms with involvement in the company, which is protection against accusations of using insider knowledge to profit. Nonetheless, the timing of Zaks' and Kim's stock sales is suspicious, leading experts and analysts to believe it could be a form of market manipulation.
Only eight people took part in the first round of the clinical trial of the coronavirus vaccine. Those eight individuals had blood levels of neutralizing antibodies—immune cells that may be able to block the coronavirus—that were on par with those seen in people who had recovered from the virus. However, it is crucial to stress how early in the process Moderna is with this trial. Only about a third of drugs that enter the clinical trial phase ever make it to final-stage testing, which is why we don't hear much about early-stage tests of new drugs and vaccines.
Table of Contents
Overview of Clinical Trials
The second phase of Moderna's clinical trial involves 600 healthy adults divided into two age groups: 18 to 55 and individuals over 55. Last week, Moderna announced that the first patients in both age groups had been vaccinated at each dosage. Each participant in the trial will receive two doses, either a high dose, a low dose, or a placebo. Throughout the year, they will be monitored for potential side effects and the presence of neutralizing antibodies against the coronavirus.
It’s important to note that only a small number of participants were involved in the initial testing phases, which raises questions about the generalizability of the results. Despite the initial excitement, experts caution that the number of participants is not sufficient to draw definitive conclusions about the vaccine's efficacy. In fact, a vaccine expert indicated that the levels of antibodies in recovered patients' plasma may not be enough to effectively neutralize the virus, suggesting that the initial results may not be as promising as they appear.
Market Reactions and Implications
Following the announcement of the first round trial results, Moderna experienced a significant surge in share prices, resulting in a $1.3 billion sale of shares to the public. However, the timing of stock sales by executives Zaks and Kim has raised eyebrows. Executives often use automated trading programs to avoid insider trading accusations, yet the proximity of their stock sales to favorable trial results raises questions about possible market manipulation.
Analysts are closely monitoring the situation, as these actions could lead to scrutiny from financial regulators. Market manipulation, defined as artificially inflating stock prices to benefit from subsequent sales, could have serious implications for investor trust and the company’s credibility.
Future Outlook for Moderna's Vaccine
As Moderna moves forward with the second stage of trials, the world is watching closely. The third trial phase is set to start in July, with estimates suggesting that a vaccine could be available on a limited basis as early as January. However, the uncertainty surrounding the results of the first phase and the investigations into Moderna's business practices necessitate a cautious approach.
Ultimately, only the completion of the trials will determine if Moderna's vaccine can effectively combat the pandemic. Until then, stakeholders will need to remain informed about the ongoing developments and potential outcomes of the trials. Understanding the complexities of vaccine development and the associated market dynamics will be crucial as we navigate this unprecedented health crisis.
